
The Tenth Circuit Finds Substantial Evidence Supported OSHA Penalties Against Management Company at Affiliate’s Facility
Companies whose personnel work at or oversee safety functions at another entity’s facility should consider the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) penalties upheld by the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals. In UHS of Delaware, Inc. v. Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission, No. 24-9521 (10th Cir. Feb. 13, 2026) the Tenth Circuit upheld administrative penalties against UHS of Delaware (a management company) arising from inadequate workplace safety and health protections at Cedar Springs Hospital. UHS challenged OSHA’s citations before the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission, the administrative body responsible for reviewing challenges to OSHA citations. Although Cedar Springs owned and operated the hospital, substantial evidence supported the Review Commission’s determination that UHS’ relationship with Cedar Springs subjected UHS to penalties for failing to provide adequate safety measures at the Cedar Springs facility.
Factors the Court Considered
The Review Commission evaluated the relationship between UHS and Cedar Springs by considering the following factors:
Common worksite. The Court considered whether there was substantial evidence to support the Review Commission’s finding that UHS and Cedar Springs employees shared a common worksite. The Court focused on where UHS employees performed work and encountered the cited hazard. UHS agreed to assign employees to serve as the hospital’s chief executive officer, chief financial officer, and chief operating officer. The parties also stipulated that UHS employees were exposed at the hospital to workplace safety and health hazards. Specifically, (i) UHS’ CFO interacted with patients during weekly visits to acute units, (ii) other UHS personnel made recurring visits to the hospital as part of their work, and (iii) UHS employees supplied executive and supervisory functions even though most hospital work was performed by Cedar Springs’ employees.
Integration of safety operations. UHS argued that there could not be integration of operation because the two companies provided different services. The Court concluded evidence of integration included sharing resources and UHS’ oversight of safety matters. UHS’ responsibilities included (i) requiring hospital staff to attend workplace safety training; (ii) providing incident-reporting forms; (iii) compiling information concerning staff injuries; (iv) reviewing and approving the hospital’s workplace-violence prevention plan; and (v) providing oversight to leaders responsible for risk management, nursing, human resources, clinical services, and plant operations.
Common Leadership or Ownership. The Court held that to support its administrative penalty OSHA must establish the entities shared a common president, management, supervision, or ownership. While there was conflicting evidence as to whether the entities shared a president, management, or supervision, both parties agreed that UHS and Cedar Springs Hospital shared a common parent company. Universal Health Services, Inc. was the ultimate parent of both entities. An intermediate subsidiary in Cedar Springs’ ownership chain did not defeat common ownership.
Takeaways
The Court held that substantial evidence supported the Review Commission’s finding that UHS was responsible for failing to provide adequate safety measures at Cedar Springs Hospital. Therefore, the Court denied UHS’ petition to review the Review Commission’s findings. Note, the court reviewed the Review Commission’s factual findings under the deferential “substantial evidence” standard. The question was whether the record reasonably supported the Review Commission’s findings, not whether the Court would have characterized the relationship differently in the first instance. The decision is instructive:
- Separate incorporation does not necessarily insulate a management or affiliated company from OSHA liability.
- Even if companies have separate and distant corporate offices, a facility may be a common worksite for OSHA’s purposes when the company’s employees perform work on the same worksite and face the hazard underlying the OSHA inspection and citation.
- A management company (including affiliated and companies related through a common parent company) may be integrated in safety matters when it directs, evaluates, approves, or supervises safety measures, even if another entity provides the facility’s primary service.
Pray Walker’s attorneys defend clients involved in administrative agency investigations, including investigations by OSHA, the U.S. Department of Labor, the Oklahoma Department of Labor, the Oklahoma Attorney General’s Office of Civil Rights Enforcement, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and the National Labor Relations Board.
If you have a question about this opinion letter or other employment questions, contact Kevin P. Doyle at kdoyle@praywalker.com.
Start a conversation
We’re here to discuss. Drop us a note and a Pray Walker attorney will connect with you.
